Review: Women of the Anarchy by Sharon Bennett Connolly

  I'll be honest - even though I studied history right through school and then at University, I never learned about the period in Englis...

Tuesday 30 March 2021

Paris in Ruins by MK Tod: Review and Interview

 I recently had the pleasure of reading a pre-publication copy of Paris in Ruins by MK Tod, which was published yesterday (March 30th, 2021) and can we take a moment to admire this fabulous cover?! 

Set in 1870, it records the experiences of two young women during the siege of Paris, when French forces were pinned down by the Prussion enemy. "Raised for a life of privilege, Camille and Mariele have much in common, but it takes the horrors of war to bring them together to fight for the people and city they love. War has a way of teaching lessons – if they can only survive to learn."

I found it an immensely gripping read. The story focuses on the two young women but both come from large families and their mothers, fathers and brothers are all also caught up in the fighting in various ways and the fate of all hangs precariously in the balance.

Camille is quite headstrong, with a tendency to ignore convention, take risks, not toe the line. Mariele is less so, at first in awe of, and perhaps a little envious of Camille. But neither is stereo-typically 'feisty' and both are hugely aware of their place in society, and their duty, despite railing against it at times. 

The horrors of war, the effects of the violence not only on the soldiers but on the civilians, are graphically and unsparingly described. The author has an economy of words which gives us the bare detail, and somehow makes it more visual. However for me the main interest lies in the development of the young women and their burgeoning awareness not only of what war can do to people's lives, but of their own place in the world. Did it take war to make them realise that marriage and children are sometimes not enough, or was it the age in which they were living? There is a stark contrast between their privileged existence and the plight of the poor of Paris. The women who live in the poorer quarters agitate for change and a powerful message comes through that women from all corners of society want, nay demand, more rights.

Woven into this driving narrative are the individual stories, the breaching of the divide between rich and poor, and the brave people who acted seemingly out of character (the actress who turns her theatre into a hospital, for example) and the social niceties which had to be ignored, to the acceptance of some and to the horror of others: moments when young ladies cannot be chaperoned, and the day that Mariele brings two poor children back to her family's grand house demonstrate that this was an age where the older generation in particular were at first scandalised and then had to grow to accept the changes all around them, changes that would endure beyond the war.

The pacing of the book is fast; rarely a page goes by without the plot moving forward, and this completely chimes with the subject matter. These were eventful, frightening times and this is expertly conveyed. A great read which I heartily recommend. It also introduced me to a period of French history about which I knew very little, so I asked Mary (MK) for a few more details.

AW: Welcome, Mary, to the blog, and congratulations on Paris in Ruins. May I begin by asking what drew you to this particular period of Parisian history? I suppose we are all more familiar with the earlier periods of revolution and war, and I did wonder whether the appeal for you was the burgeoning of the women's rights movement?

MKT: Thanks, Annie. I wish I could say that I was driven by the women’s rights movement, being a feminist myself. However, the real reason has to do with another novel I wrote—Lies Told In Silence—and the interest expressed by readers to learn more about Mariele, a woman who featured in that novel as Helene’s grandmother. So I did the math and figured out that Mariele would have been about 20 in 1870, and voila, the Franco-Prussian war.

AW: I know that Sarah Bernhardt was a real person but I had no idea of her tireless work during the siege. Were any of the other characters - apart from the generals and political leaders - based on real people?

MKT: Several of the people involved in the Commune are real: Auguste Blanqui, Emile Keratry, Paule Minck. But the only other real person that I turned into a character is Louise Michel, leader of the Montmartre Women’s Vigilance Committee, and a woman that Camille spies on. Louise Michel was a feminist, a writer, and an anarchist. She was also one of the founders of the Society for the Rights of Women (La Société du Droit des Femmes). Louise believed passionately that women should have autonomy and equality and she actually fought as a soldier during the Paris Commune.

AW: How difficult was it for you to research? I understand that much of the history can be learned from source material but your detailed descriptions of the streets and buildings in Paris suggest to me that you've visited in person? If so, was it relatively easy to find the buildings mentioned in the novel?

MKT: Paris In Ruins benefited from the discovery of several first-person accounts of the siege and commune that were written in English. It also benefited from a three-week visit my husband and I made to Paris where I took so many photos, visited all of the places mentioned in the novel, and took in several museums that featured 19th century Paris. We had a marvellous time absorbing that unique atmosphere that Paris has to offer.

AW: Finally I must thank you for the opportunity to read Paris in Ruins and ask where your writing will be taking you next?

MKT: You are so welcome! I have two novels in different stages at the moment. One is set in early twentieth century Hong Kong and is on submission with several publishing houses. The other is a contemporary novel—a first for me—about identical twins one of whom disappears to expose a crime while the other takes over her life.

Many thanks for inviting me on you blog today, Annie. It’s a true pleasure to talk about my writing. 

AW: You're welcome, thanks for chatting today. Readers can find Paris in Ruins:

"Paris 1870. Raised for a life of parties and servants, Camille and Mariele have much in common, but it takes the horrors of war to bring them together to fight for the city they love. War has a way of teaching lessons – if only they can survive to learn them."

And you can find MK Tod on Facebook, Twitter, and on her Blog


Wednesday 3 March 2021

Review/Interview: Snares and Delusions by HM Holten

Today I'm delighted to welcome author Hanne Holten, author of Snares and Delusions, a book which I read a while ago and is one of those novels which stayed with me long after I'd finished reading it. The book begins in rural nineteenth-century Sweden and reading these earlier chapters is like looking at a painting while an expert points out every detail for you. Hedda is competent, capable, and stifled by society's and her own family's expectations. Relief from the daily grind and her father's plans for her comes from the family of a young man whom she befriends. In Kaspar's company, and in the crowded but loving home of his family, she experiences what it might be like to be part of a family where she might be appreciated.

However, life has other plans for her, and we follow her as she travels to Denmark and we meet characters who surprise and appall in equal measure. This is historical fiction, but not quite as we normally encounter it. To give details of Hedda's life away from her childhood home would be to give too many spoilers but it is a story of challenges, abuse, fear, determination and survival. The book is so unlike any other I've read that I had to talk to Hanne to find out more about her, her writing, and this novel in particular.

AW: Welcome to the blog Hanne!

HH: Thank you, Annie, for inviting me. I’m delighted to answer your questions about Snares and Delusions.

Young Girl, Copenhagen

AW: One of the things I enjoyed most about the book was the stunning Scandinavian backdrop. I'd like to begin by talking about your background. I know you have Scandinavian family connections. How much did this inspire/influence the story? Were any of the characters - however loosely - based on real people?

HH: Yes, I have Scandinavian roots and grew up in Denmark. I lived in England when I decided to write this book and it seemed natural for me to delve into my family history for a subject. More so, because of the mystery that surrounded my great-grandmother. All I knew was that she was born somewhere in the south of Sweden, that she’d lived in Jutland for a while, that she came to Copenhagen around the turn of the century and had a boarding house. Her daughter was born in 1902. I also knew that she was a bit of a shrew and that attracted me too.

With so little knowledge of her background and history, I felt free to use my fantasy. Let me add that writing Snares and Delusions took me a long time. I went through several phases but kept coming back to the material with new ideas. Hedda changed considerably through this process. The final form – of dreams and nightmares – it received when I joined the writers’ group Authonomy.

Young Swedish Fiddler
AW: In my introduction, I mentioned Kaspar and his family. I found that the scenes where they appeared gave an insight into life in that region and at that time, as well as providing a contrast with Hedda's home life. Kaspar himself is an accomplished fiddler and Tom plays the flute. With your musical background, how important was it for you to feature music in the story?

HH: It was important for me to bring in the music as a counterpoint to Hedda’s family and the Dalquists [AW: the rich neighbouring family into whom Hedda must marry]. Also, I felt that I could use my knowledge of music to create some believable characters and get their ‘accomplishments’ right. To that comes the fact that folk music has a high standing in Sweden, and there is a rich tradition for travelling musicians, especially fiddlers.

AW: I think it came across so clearly that they had a sense of purpose and pride in their accomplishment, and contentment with their lives. Speaking of tradition, Hedda is what we might term a ‘free spirit’ but is constrained utterly by societal expectations of her. What came across really strongly in the book was that others constantly attempted to map her path, and her struggles with that. Is her experience typical of women of this era in Scandinavia?

HH: There is no doubt that women were constrained in both the Swedish and Danish society. No woman could own anything, the moment she married. Often a parson’s widow would be forced to marry the minister following her husband's death. There are examples of women, notably Amalie Skram, an author born in Norway, who spent two periods in asylums. The first asylum phase was caused by her husband’s infidelity, and on recovering, she left him and moved to Denmark. The following episode was orchestrated by her second husband. After she was discharged, she left him and continued writing several novels. She takes place as one of the first feminists in Scandinavia.

Amelie Skram

Naturally, these mores and events were also issues that inspired me to write Snares and Delusions.

AW: Yes, I finished the book feeling that Hedda lived in a time of almost-change, where women wanted more than society was prepared to give them. Times were changing, but not fast enough for the likes of Hedda. Thank you so much for talking to me today, Hanne, and sharing some details on the background to the novel.


Readers wishing to find out more about Hanne and her writing can find her:

On her blog: https://holten.co.uk

Her Amazon Author Page: https://www.amazon.com/author/hm_holten

On her Goodreads Page: https://www.goodreads.com/author/show/17619872.H_M_Holten

And on Twitter: https://twitter.com/HoltenHm